|
TABLE OF CONTENTS - PROSE
Mental Health and Mental Illness
- Paul Nachbar
Existential Panic Disorder - Paul
Nachbar
"Technically" Haiku - Kay Lindgren
Poetry Definition - Mark Norman
Troops; Anecdotal Experiences
- Thomas Hadley
National Sour Grapes Day - Paul Nachbar
Dialogue of the Pican Deities
- Paul Nachbar
Between Rocks and a Hard Spot
- Paul Nachbar
Mental Health and Mental Illness
- Paul Nachbar
I do not think I can change the world in nearly any way but I can certainly
define what hit me and nearly finished me off in this world. And which
has nearly finished off dozens or hundreds or thousands or millions of
people in some very subtle ways. If I cannot change the world, nor can
I free it, which might not even be desirable in many ways. But I can cultivate
my own garden which is the Pico Society as best I can and hope for the
best. Imagine the world as a network of hierarchies which are basically
run by a small number people and corporations and not machines-- since
machines and science and other things of this ilk are not sentient beings
but the tools and symbols of sentient beings.--and where millions of people,
if not billions, form the bottom tiers of knowledge workers. of one kind
or another. I am not saying this is perhaps not inevitable and am certainly
not calling for any sort of revolution from below against those who are
above, just perhaps more awareness. of what is really going on and in
a systematic way. Though, although I do not mind religion in any sense
these days, except for the more narrow and restrictive and biased ways
in which religion sometimes manifests itself..like any other social institution...and
across the board of nearly all religions..I do mind some of the things
that apparently are used to hold all of this together., that is the seemingly
prevailing ideas of mental health and mental illness. If one cannot "function"
in one's allotted slot in the hierarchy of knowledge workers, plus the
allotted social or familial slots appropriate to such , then one is deemed
"mentally ill". If one can function within those slots, then
one is deemed "mentally healthy". These definitions are in many
places so prevalent that it is difficult to assert anything positive about
such human accomplishments which traditionally have been quasi-independent
of such "structures" and apart from them, such as art, music,
theatre, poetry etc. In the structural-functional approach of those who
run this system, which may after all be the best possible of all systems,
such things are close to or related to or analogous to mental illness
even if they are not mental illness themselves. Therefore thinking, feeling,
imagining anything outside of what the experts deem to be functional and
normal..and useful in terms of your input as labor into this social system
is disregarded, disrespected and shunted aside. You can see this in the
flood of articles by psychologists linking "mental illness"
with creativity in extreme forms., research which seems empirical in it's
method but is intensely biased towards the functioning of the status quo,
not the investigation of human nature or possibilities per se. I do not
claim that this is the case in any situation but it is easily imaginable,
given an "evil corporation" or an "evil expert" or
some collaboration of the two to turn a formerly free labor force into
a labor force composed of psychological slaves. No I do not mean addicted
to psychiatric or other medications or to the process so-called of therapy
or to so-called "behaviors" which do not fit into somebody's
ideas on what is "best for the greatest number of people" eg,
modern utilitarianism.,. but people who have no force of will or individuality
because of the deliberate attempts of the "evil corporation"
and "evil expert" to break down all traces of individuality,
likes and dislikes, ambitions outside the "norm" etc, through
repeated applications of one modality so-called or another of "behavioral
modification", "cognitive therapy"
or medications..That is, such a thing is not inconceivable in this world
which has also fairly deliberately created many major disasters and holocausts
in every time and place I know of. Here the individual knowledge worker,
isolated from any form of social organization which supports his or her
demands or needs, in many cases, is
thrust before the immense power of the experts, dangling "mental
health:" in front
of them, with all the lovely and mostly fictional consequences of before
and after pictures while being fully aware of the dreadful consequences
of "mental illness" or being imagined as mentally ill..Now how
is that for a description of what at least can happen , uh, theoretically?
back to top
Existential Panic Disorder - Paul
Nachbar
I had given up and was no longer the little engine that could, but more
the little engine that really should have or perhaps the little engine
that didn't really want to or the little engine that made excuses or the
little engine that somehow got waylaid or whatever. This was not pleasant
of course because all around me people were trying and doing and working
and struggling or succeeding or failing with one thing or another, which
may or may not have meant anything, and who was I to stay there so stalled
and inert? Get a job, get a life! I upbraided myself but it was no go.
Just didn’t work, couldn't work. And I had been to a lot of specialists
too who could either find nothing wrong or found different things wrong
with me or gave me tons of advice which was very interesting but had no
real connection with my specific engine problems. Not that
I was the world's best patient, I knew, but if they knew exactly what
they were doing and not just approximately, then certainly I'd get fixed
and go back to where I was in that giant concourse of existence. What
to do? It is an imperfect world. One can't expect too much. So mainly
I just lay there on my couch, prone, spinning my wheels and quite helplessly
and hopelessly getting nowhere, or at least nowhere real beyond the couch.
One day a friend of a friend told me about this Great Expert Among Experts
who was in town and whom I really needed to see. This guy, she said, was
so knowledgeable about these things, well, he was a world-class authority
on problems like mine. And besides, for a limited time, he was making
evaluations of patients at a reduced rate. Hey, world class expert AND
bargain basement discounts; who could ask for anything more? So I dragged
my burnt-out and broken self - though I did not always seem as broken
and burnt out to others as I felt, even though they knew I was sincere
into the city where I met with the fellow, a Dr X, in an extremely elaborate
apartment. Funny session, though. I told Dr Z, who seemed laser-sharp
in his concentration and focus about all of my symptoms, about my interpretation
of the scenes and situations which had led to my mechanical breakdown,
about all the methods I had tried to use to repair things, to what extent
these worked or didn’t work, how others had tried to intervene and
what the consequences were and my sense of all the different nterpretations
of what had happened to me which seemed to apply and not apply at the
same time. Anyway, I told Dr Z that it had been a very long time since
I had functioned, that I just didn't know what to do, and that I felt
a mixture of anger, guilt, obsessiveness, suspicion, apathy, vengefulness,
shame, despair and a host of other engine-clotting ingredients which should
really happen to nobody. But perhaps all these things were just too complicated,
I hypothesized out loud, and the real truth was that I was a hopeless
case and that nobody could deal with me or motivate me to anything? Or,
as Jim Morrison once said, that "nobody gets out of here alive."
Dr Z, by the way, liked Jim Morrison, which I appreciated-- hey, a hip
psychiatrist--though disagreed of
course.
"No, no, no. None of these observations are really completely accurate
my friend. None of the diagnoses. None of the previous treatment. Close,
perhaps, at one time or another, but no cigar." I was afraid here
of what the good doctor was going to recommend, since some of the treatments
for maladies like mine could be very strenuous and dangerous. So I just
sat there in a spirit of anxious hesitation. "Well, what exactly
is wrong with me? " I asked, thinking more along the lines, since
I could not help myself, "and what did I do to deserve this?"
"I'd say" responded Dr Z, after some moments of profound hesitation,
"that this is a severe case of what may be termed Existential Panic
Disorder." This sounded good, though I had never heard of such a
diagnosis before, and instantly imagined trading such a diagnosis with
my similarly diagnosed friends , wondering what their reactions would
be here...disbelief, jealousy, awe at the analytical insight of Dr Z,
whom they probably would not have the privilege to meet. Of course I was
not accustomed to questioning things here, that is, I was not assertive
with mental health professionals, and it took me awhile to raise the humble
question, "now exactly what does this mean? And exactly what are
the consequences?"
This was a fearful moment or series of moments. I held my breath. I was
very orried. It could be anything. I upbraided myself again for any excess
anxiety I might be showing, even though it seemed my future held in the
balance scales of the good doctor's fine polished and practiced insight
and fine intelligence. What were the cure rates, I wondered. What were
the appropriate medications? Would I end up--I sighed to myself--in one
of those really bad places one could end up in but which one could never
complain about because nobody could really listen? The suspense was endless.
Finally, Dr Z intoned with the vaguest trace of a smile, "Existential
Panic Disorder basically means, my good man, that you are, well, alive."
I knew that of course, so what was he trying to tell me here? Something
new? Something bad? I wasn't sure. I couldn't think and was ready to blank
out. or crawl under the desk..well this was a
fantasy..I would never do anything so inappropriate.
The good doctor thumbed through several of the ancient volumes of medical
lore in his bookshelves and dusted off one of the shelves casually with
a finger. I was waiting here in suspense for some additional information
but nothing. I should be patient. I should not assume. I should just shut
up , I guess, until it was appropriate to speak. I felt bad. I mean, I
really felt awful. A total sense of dread. The good doctor then flipped
casually through one of the magazines on his desk, filled with articles
about The Recent War and Crime and Terrorism and Drugs and the Breakup
of the Family and Unemployment and all sorts of other issues. I felt humbled.
Of what significance were my petty problems? I was wasting his time, perhaps?
Was I merely lazy and irresponsible? I did not know. I wanted answers
and fast. "Well," I finally asked, “what is the prognosis
here? " I watched him thinking and could imagine the sophisticated
and fine-tuned gears of his mind considering every case, every possibility,
every cross reference, every methodology, every accumulated bit of wisdom,
knowledge and insight that the field of psychiatry had obtained in over
a hundred
years I was very anxious and gulped again. I hope he did not notice. "Yes,
yes, "he repeated, "Existential Panic Disorder. With utmost
certainty ". Then he paused. "The diagnosis is." Another
pause. "And yes, you are alive." I was not sure how to respond
to this, though I guess part of this conclusion was self-evident, was
it not? I don’t know, maybe i was missing something. "And the
prognosis"? I finally brought myself to say in a much softer voice.
I was truly suffering. Everybody knew I had been suffering. Previous experts
had rated my level of psychological suffering as a nine on a scale of
zero to ten. Dr Z was silent here. I too paused. "Did I do something
wrong, doctor?" He looked at me intensely and then raised his hands
in a apparently compassionate but somewhat futile gesture. "I mean,
is there a cure? I really have not been doing so hot., you know. I've
read a great deal of the literature here and am still, like very, very
confused...Really confused. Am I stupid?" The good doctor again looked
at me and I saw a wince of pain on his knotted brow, though this might
have just been a twitch or, well, anything. I did not know. He seemed
at first impatient and then calmer. "Nobody knows what you should
do. Uh, do you want to be a doctor?" "A doctor?" I asked
him
surprised, "why a doctor?" "Well," he said, "frankly
it's a good living and.... there are always plenty of sick people."
Another pause and then a vaguely dramatic rise in the pitch of his voice,
"it is..a pretty sick world out there, you know?" This professional
possibility seemed somewhat attractive but no, not in my condition, whatever
that was, and I think Dr Z agreed here. I was a victim of and perhaps
survivor of Existential Panic Disorder, which seemed as good a label as
any and better than most I had heard.. "No, " I concluded, reluctantly,
"all things considered, that's probably not for me". "I
know what you mean" he finally said, "medicine is practical
of course but is really not such a lovely field., you know? And as far
as what to do. well, REALLY what to here in cases like THIS...well, nobody
knows. I know they SOUND like they know but..nobody has ever KNOWN, to
be quite honest here. But good luck to you.. I mean, the best of luck.,
my friend" He smiled and I think here with some genuine warmth, though
perhaps he was considering some aspects of his schedule, who knows? We
shook hands, I took the train back from the city and once again, I lay
on my couch, in my usual agony, wondering once again what all of this
meant, before drifting off to a long, long dark deep sleep.
back to top
"Technically" Haiku
- Kay Lindgren
Nice! As for what is "technically" haiku, there are so many
rules and so many schools of thought that the issue becomes confusing.
In English, the five-seven-five syllable rule is eschewed by some modern
poets who think that it encourages padding with particles such as "the,"
"a," etc. These poets say that Japanese makes said syllable
count a virtual necessity because of the structure of that language. English,
according to these modern poets, calls for fewer syllables in the lines.
I have seen modern haiku with short syllable counts, such as two-four-two.
That is economy of words!
Some of the rules of classical Japanese haiku follow. The poem is to
present one crystallized image or moment in nature. You are to see a mental
image of one natural element only when you read the poem - a tree, a flower,
a weather phenomenon. No subjectivity or emotion is to enter into the
poem. It is to be completely detached from the emotional or judgmental
standpoint. Once emotions or personal opinions enter into the poem, it
becomes a senryu instead of a haiku. If the poem makes the reader laugh
or feel nostalgia, anger, loneliness, sadness, love or any human emotion,
it is probably a senryu. In haiku, simile, a comparison using "like"
or "as," is taboo. Metaphor, however, is allowed and often drives
the haiku. Finally, a haiku in the purest sense will mention the season
of the year by name or give a clear indication as to which season it is.
There are probably more rules. I will venture that the members of a
group of haikuists would be likely to disagree and argue many
points. My bottom line is therefore this: Anything goes.
back to top
Poetry Definition - Mark Norman
Poetry is,
capturing the careening boulder of emotion, thought, or fact; compressing
it into a small pebble by applying the force of intellect; then polishing
it into a gem with the jeweler's cloth of harmonic phonics.
back to top
Troops; Anecdotal Experiences
- Thomas Hadley
i was a cold-warrior only shooting only targets, receiving only political
flak, personal snipings ..many a day, many a night, I wished that I was
back home... having surrendered my civil rights to a great degree to protect
those who were back there, at home... i missed first steps, baby laughs,
my love lay abed cold and lonely, the bruised knee got no daddy's kiss
but the cause was noble, sacrifices just... when you're away, you realize
how much we have here at home.. if you get a chance, you make your Holiday
cheer, gather your younger soldiers and comrades over... you make family
where none was there... my favorite Christmas Eve was when we had Jan's
friend and her Blackhawk tech sergeant hubby over for supper, for our
wee ones to open just one present. I had bagged a fine pheasant in the
vineyards the day before, and dressed him in bacon, stuffed with wild
rice.... fresh broetchen, butter so rich, all the trimmings...Christmas
in Germany was wonderful. The gluhwein, the Kristkindl Markt, the lack
of tawdry hype. Imagine Iraq and Afghanistan, now. Still, they will make
family where there was none. Presents will be sent, and received. The
turkey and feasting will have begun long before we awake at home, here.
Some peace and magic
will be snatched out of the gritty cold gloom. The human spirit prevails.
back to top
National Sour Grapes Day - Paul Nachbar
Given many of the demographic factors of at least American society and
probably others, though I am far less familiar with these cases (cases
in all senses of the word) I propose here a National Sour Grapes Day.
Being more of a theoretical and imaginitive, even sometimes imaginary
person, than a so-called practical or even pragmatic person, I cannot
propose any details here. Though given human nature at it's usual worst,
outlining hte details at some future date might be an excellent idea.But
in general, the National Sour Grapes Day would be a day for all members
of all groups who argue/fight/hate each other to somehow, in a fairly
safe environment, bombard each other with these griveances in a direct
non-manipulative and not destructive manner. And then people can possibley
do what they sometimes claim to do --just 'get over it', 'not sweat the
small stuff'--and all those other glitzy slogans people use to paper over
inevitable sociological conflicts in a multi-ethnic multi-special-interest-oriented
society. Of course such an event would have to be moderated by somebody
who is fair and reasonable, that is somebody who basically does not like
in some sense all human subgroupings..I have no idea who that might be.
I do not consider that sponsoring such an event would be costly and it
would have the salutorious effect, I think, of transferring extra income
away from various onstituencies who are, in general, already paid sufficiently,
to wit, mental health professionals, certain classes of lawyers, certain
classes of advice-dispensers, and the numerous businesses which capitalize
fairly deliberately on the so-called neuroses or psychooses even which
are inevitably produced by the inevitable social frictions in this particular
society at this particular time, not limited of course to the manufacturers
and ispensers of legal as well as illicit social relaxants and stimulants.
ALso including on this list the various authorities with a financial insterest
in steering funds towards their individual states for the construction
of prisons and mental institutions to treat/punish individuals 'guilty'
of misdemeanors and felonies in the so-called 'war against drugs' eg,
what people tend to use, in valid short-term if not long-term judgments
to cope with inevitable social frictions.
If this is not a disadvantage, the second advantage is that such a National
Holiday could be fun and actualy cut down on certain types of crime, which
are due to pent-up individual frustrations certian classes of individuals
will experience due to our American sociological structure eg, so-called
"sociopaths' or "psychopaths" who are usually located/analyzed
by socio-demographic methods eg., single white, often highly intelligent
males who 'did not fit in', 'did not have stable patterns of relationships'
etc..Then of course, we can go back to football, baseball, basketball,
soccer, the so-called democractic political system we have and all the
other ways people have of enjoying themselves, making some money or getting
vicarious enjoyment and compensating themselves for not being William
Gates..
back to top
Dialogue of the Pican Deities -
Paul Nachbar
A: I'd say here after much consideration that this experiment with the
concept of Freedom has been an absolute failure.These ridiculous creatures
down below have proven themselves to be mere over-animated cartoons or
shadows or flickers of nothing much at all.They have utterly failed at
any of their tasks given every possible opportunity.Truly,a hopeless bunch,
my friends!Absolutely hopeless indeed! And yes, it does infuriate me.I
must admit, though this emotion is far beneath me.Ahem. I propose we erase
everything, including THEM from the drawing board and perhaps start again.
Or perhaps not.This has been a costly activity, too, and besides I'm bored.<yawns
broadly>Really, havent we BETTER things to do with our time?
B. No, you are impatient, A.Give them time.They will change.Or evolve
Or adjust. Though I must confess here to my own intense disappointment
with the experiment.Which I guess is the way it SEEMS.If madness is repetition,
which to some extent it is, they have proven themselves utterly mad and
to the core. They do the same thing, play the same games, fall into the
same traps, make the same errors again and again.If it were not so tragic,
it would be comic. Though I do not laugh.Not at all. And this is not merely
my investment here.
Yes, again I say I am disappointed with the results. But I speak for hope.
If one part in ten fails, then perhaps one part in one hundred will succeed,
and if one part in one hundred fails, then perhaps one part in a thousand,
or ten thousand, or a hundred thousand or a million or even a billion.
But who knows? I am disappointed but I still hope. Though I am too weary
now to make a final decision.but I beg you, though demoralized, to stay
your hand, A.
What do you think, C?
C: Think? Hahaha! Why bother thinking? The whole thing is the broadest
of comedies, my fellows! Why think at all? Did you expect "success"
here? If so, you were deceived.We have the power and the glory here. If
they do not, then what the hell did you expect? No, it is ridiculous but
amusing.Sit with me and observe their doings without hope or anger, for
these are a waste of energy:No, they are merely silly, so enjoy? I merely
enjoy, having divested myself of all investments here for their tragedies
are not my tragedies.Why get so involved? Ah, well, a matter of taste
I suppose and I must admit these creatures are not precisely to my liking
and do not possess in my eyes the quality of beauty. But that is me. Well,
well. They upset you to rage or torment you into false hope. I am with
you, of course, but personally I would simply, to use their phrase, change
the channel here. They 'fail' or 'succeed'. So what? There are a million
million million million other worlds to observe out there and who is to
say which is more significant than any other? What do you think E?
E: I am absolutely indifferent,C, having other affairs more worthy of
consideration and of far greater importance.What happened, happens or
could happen there is of no consequence to me. Very sorry. I think you'd
be better off asking D.It's all a numbers game, my friends and their numbers
do not interest me. You'd be better off asking E, you know?
D: I diverge.I am neither angry nor hopeful nor amused by all of this.Nor
of course absolutely indifferent.My mind is not the clearest of our group
and I never claimed this, but I am indifferent to nothing. Yes, there
are reasons and perfectly valid ones for anger or hope or laughter or
even indifference .But all is not as it seems. Or what I mean here is
that not all is, well, as DULL as it often seems (a round of laughter
occurs among the assembled deities) I think..well..to be rather sneaky
about it..some rather interesting crimes have occured here and things
out of the ordinary and things not quite knowable. Not that this is so
evident. One must look quite closely and at things invisible to many eyes
and inaudible to many ears.
A: Hmmm..What do you mean?
D: I cannot define...exactly. But it is..interesting, as I am sure you
will agree. Listen:
[the following text, of far greater length than the above fragments,has
been deleted for the sake of the preservation and furtherance of the human
species]
back to top
Between Rocks and a Hard Spot
- Paul Nachbar
Between the group and the individual
Between the consensus and what probably is true about this Between what
is true and improbable in the individual Between the necessary and unnecessary
suffering Between the so-called superfical and the so-called profound
Between the different kinds of power and knowledge Between your choices
Between the books about your choices Between what you were taught and
what you actually see Between what you would like to believe and what
you know Between what is said and what is not said Between your desire
to be and not be yourself Between the stated certainty and the actual
uncertainty Between the stated uncertainty and the actual certainty Between
the angels and devils who may just be inside of you Or who may not exist
at all for all you really know Between the faithful and the faithless
Between the truth-telling liars and the lying truth-tellers Between the
world and the many ideas of it Between the necessity to simplify and the
necessity to expand Between the gutwrench of pain and the fine cerebration
Between the hope and the despair Between the practical the impractical
Between this place and that place Between this time and that time Between
this one and that one Between those who know and those who don't And those
who may or may not know..or is this all of them? Between the ones who
think too little and the ones who think too much? Between the ones who
seem to feel too little and the ones who seem to feel too much? Between
the ones who seem to imagine too much and the ones who seem to imagine
too little Between the ones who talk or do too much and the ones who talk
or do too little Between the present, past, and future..
There I encounter you.
Not just---it is what it is. It is ALL that it is. .
back to to
|